Chapbook Review: Visiting Writers
Written by Ravi Mangla
Uncanny Valley Press, 2011
Ravi Mangla’s chapbook, Visiting Writers (Uncanny Valley Press, 2011), consists of 23 pieces of flash fiction. These pieces each describe a chance encounter with a famous writer—removed from the trappings of academia or pop-culture consumption, these slices of life peer into the characters of Flannery O’Connor, Vladimir Nabokov, Charles Bukowski, Grace Paley, and other notables. Mangla’s chapbook wants to provide fun little glimpses into humanizing moments—in the candid space, the writers behave in ways that give sly glances into the idiosyncratic quirks that may or may not have shaped their own writings. It attempts to link art and artist. Unfortunately, in many of the pieces, it comes off as too obvious. I appreciate that each piece is resolute in its brevity, but ultimately these short visits into the lives of famous authors don’t use their few phrases to any advantage. The journey comes off as somewhat contrived, as each reference to a new author reads more like a library manifest than a story.
That said, I also appreciate the way Mangla tries to keep things low-key despite the misplaced high-brow platitudes. Bits of humor keep things light, such as the following two-sentence piece: “At the DMV I waited in line behind Gordon Lish. He wanted a custom license plate but couldn’t settle on the right combination of letters.” It’s a neat little nod to Lish’s reputation as a meticulous wordsmith. The collection is full of these inside jokes for well-read audiences, but the end result of these little gems doesn’t have staying power—it just reads like a laundry list of winks from Mangla that become almost expected and anticipated by the end of the chapbook.
This first chapbook from Ravi Mangla has an ambitious premise, but it doesn’t meet expectations. However, Visiting Writers represents a step toward a more cohesive authorial voice for Mangla. There is evidence of Mangla’s attention to detail throughout the chapbook, and even if the chapbook fell flat for me, I imagine that some of Mangla’s stylistic choices will evolve and serve him better in his next collection. All writers grow and learn as they revise their work, listen to critics (or ignore them as necessary), and reflect on past projects. I sometimes wretch when looking back at my work from five years or even five minutes ago; Ravi Mangla’s piece is fine-tuned enough that it doesn’t force this gag reflect, but it still misses the mark. So this brutal review aside, Mangla may be an author to watch. Visiting Writers was contrived, and it almost used its premise as a crutch—hiding behind its literary references while failing to impress on its own merits—but when Mangla steps into his next project, the undercurrents of craft in Visiting Writers could come to the surface in an amazing way.
Review by James R. Gapinski
© 2012, All Rights Reserved
© 2012, All Rights Reserved